Paint vs Stain: Which is the Better Option for Your Deck?

Jun 13, 2023

As homeowners, we all want our outdoor spaces to look their best. One common area that often needs attention is the deck. Over time, the elements can take a toll on the deck’s appearance, making it necessary to consider options for rejuvenation. Painting and staining are two popular choices, each offering unique benefits and considerations. In this blog post, we’ll delve into the differences between painting and staining a deck, exploring pricing, timeline, and maintenance, to help you make an informed decision for your home.

What to Know About Staining Your Deck

If you are in love with the look of wood and just want to add a little color, then stain is the way to go. It comes in a variety of shades and opacities so that you can choose the stain that will give you the look you are going for. But, if you are staining a deck you should keep in mind that you will have to re-stain it on a regular basis – about once a year. This is because stain doesn’t sit on top 0f the wood and coat it – it actually soaks into the fibers of the wood. As time goes on the sun and weather diminish the appearance of the pigments. Using a stain that is opaque will provide the most protection, color, and longevity.

Staining a deck offers a more natural and subtle enhancement, allowing the wood’s natural beauty to shine through. Here’s a few more things to consider about choosing stain for your deck:

Pricing: Staining a deck is generally more cost-effective than painting. The cost of stain, labor, and prep work is typically lower. This is due to the fact that solid stains require two coats whereas stains can be done with one coat, depending on the base.

Timeline: Staining a deck is often a quicker process compared to painting. After cleaning and sanding the deck, the stain can be applied directly. Stain typically dries faster than paint, allowing for a quicker turnaround time. In general, staining a deck can be completed within a few days, depending on the deck’s size and condition.

Maintenance: Stained decks require regular maintenance to retain their appearance and protect the wood from moisture and UV damage. Typically, a stained deck should be resealed every two to three years. This process involves cleaning the deck, applying a fresh coat of stain, and allowing it to dry properly. With proper maintenance, a stained deck can retain its beauty for many years.

What to Know About Painting Your Patio or Deck

Painting a deck can be an excellent way to add a burst of color and personality to your outdoor space.

The word “paint” is used often when referring to a solid stain, which is a self-priming, completely opaque coating designed to be walked on, unlike standard house paint, which is designed for more vertical surfaces like siding, trim, etc.

Solid stain is also going to give your patio the best possible, longest-lasting protection against the elements. A good coat of solid stain will help protect the wood from the constant swelling and shrinking associated with water retention and drying. If done correctly, applying a solid stain could last you almost 7-8 years depending on sun exposure.

A bonus advantage of using a solid stain on your deck is in the instance of a deck extension project. After the addition, the entire deck could be painted using a solid coating for a uniform look for your whole project.

Here’s a few more things to consider about choosing solid stain for your deck:

Pricing: Choosing solid stain for a deck typically involves higher upfront costs compared to staining, due to the need for a second application for each project.

Timeline: Painting a deck requires multiple steps to ensure the solid stain will adhere to the surface. The deck must be thoroughly cleaned, sanded, and any repairs will be made before applying the solid stain. On average, expect a deck project to take anywhere from a few days to a week, depending on the deck’s size and condition.

Maintenance: Solid stain provides excellent protection against the elements. Paint can chip and peel over time, especially in high-traffic areas. To maintain a painted deck, periodic touch-ups and repainting of selected spots may be necessary every few years to keep it looking fresh and vibrant.

When it comes to deciding between painting and staining your deck, there are various factors to consider, including pricing, timeline, and maintenance. Painting offers a vibrant and customizable finish but requires more extensive prep work and long-term maintenance. On the other hand, staining provides a natural and elegant look, with a quicker application process and relatively low maintenance requirements.

Ultimately, the choice between painting and staining depends on your personal preferences, budget, and the desired aesthetic for your outdoor space. Consulting with a professional painting company can help you assess your deck’s condition and make an informed decision. Whichever option you choose, a fresh coat of paint or stain can breathe new life into your outdoor spaces, making them areas of your home where you can make memories for years to come.

Ready to Get Started?